i've got the husky's in my truck, i really like them, but have not looked at the weathertech, yes the lip by the door is annoying, tends to let some stuff hit the carpet. as far as ice and snow goes i have to dump them pretty often...which sucks. and no curling yet, had them 4 months, and I tend to put anywhere from 1000-3000 miles a month on the truck...so im in and out of it ALOT!.