if you deal with a lot of snow, then the weathertech is the way to go. With my experiance with rough long winters and tons of snow, thehusky liners will just collect the snow then it'll melt into a pool of water then turn to ice when you get out and shut down. At least with the weathertech you will still have ridges over the ice. I already have about 2 feet of snow on the ground and temps around 0. Gotta love the great white north.